Protective Rejections in Consumer Credit
Paying out the loan raises 18-month default by 20.3 percentage points for the applicants whom the weekend delay keeps from borrowing.
If a rejected applicant doesn't default, was the rejection a mistake, or did it protect them?
758,622 applications on a Finnish loan-comparison platform, linked to credit-register defaults for every applicant, funded or not. Among applicants who already have an offer, those who apply Friday to Sunday wait longer for the payout, and fewer of them borrow. That weekend delay is the instrument.
Without the loan these applicants default at 12.65%, below the 14.3% rate at which a loan breaks even, so they look like false rejections. With the loan they default at 32.9%: rejecting a hundred of them avoids twenty defaults. One default offsets the profit on six repaid loans, so each avoided default lets lenders approve more applicants who would repay.